Physical Fitness 1.5 Times More Effective Than Other Therapies for Mental Health: Study
Earlier in 2023, The University of South Australia conducted a study review encompassing 1,039 studies with over 128,000 participants, which linked physical fitness practices to mental wellness.
Subjects of the studies had varying demographics, a cross-section of the population, not all with a pre-existing diagnosis of a mental health disorder. Any and all kinds of physical fitness practices were included in the studies and noted according to duration and intensity of the exercise. Mental health data was taken and analyzed based on several scales, as well as self-reports.
Here are some findings from the review:
- Exercise has a significant impact on mental health issues and disorders, including anxiety and depression.
- The overall data shows that physical exercise may be 1.5 times more effective than traditional counseling or pharmaceutical intervention.*
- The most significantly impacted populations for positive change include women with chronic illness, pre and post natal women, and people living with HIV.
- Moderate to intense exercise had a more positive impact than lower intensity.
- Exercising 150 minutes or less per week had a more positive impact than more time working out.
- Programmed or prescribed exercise plans of 12 weeks had a more positive impact than not having an exercise plan.
Mental health is important for everyone, not just those diagnosed with a disorder. Most people undergo stress from daily life, or can have temporary bouts of depression and anxiety. This study review shows the positive mental health benefit of physical activity for everyone, not just those in medical care for a diagnosis.
The World Health Organization estimates that mental health disorders rose significantly over the years of 2020-21, with a baseline before the COVID-19 pandemic to be about 12.5% of the global population. That number is unclear in 2023, as some people suffered significant temporary stress, and some continue to struggle. Lifestyle changes have been discussed and suggested for many years around mental health, but this is one of the first studies to show that it may be more effective for some people than counseling, therapy, or medications.*
In addition, because mental health is not seen as a physical symptom in many people, the numbers reported by World Health Organization may be lower than the actual number of people with underlying mental health issues, including many levels of anxiety and depression.
*This study does not imply that people should leave their current practices in therapy, or that they should quit taking their medications. This study quantifies prescribing physical activity as part of a mental health care plan, and shows that lifestyle changes can have a significant impact on people’s mental health. It also shows that people who are not in therapy or taking medication may still get significant positive results from a simple exercise plan.
